
01Gold Standard
Unknown
hidden-gemusa
DTC only; small production runs; widely considered by cast iron aficionados to have the best handle design in the industry. Stargazer is part of the 'New Wave' of American cast iron. Unlike Lodge (which has a pebbly texture), Stargazer is machined smooth, mimicking vintage Griswold pans. Their standout feature is the flared rim for drip-free pouring and a bifurcated handle that stays cool on the stovetop. They sell almost exclusively DTC, keeping prices lower than competitors like Butter Pat or Smithey.
Quality Score10/12
Purity
Evidence
Transparency
Value
Moderate Evidence