Carmina Shoemaker 80201 Forest Cap-Toe Oxford
01Gold Standard
Carmina Shoemaker·Footwear

80201 Forest Cap-Toe Oxford

$495
oxfordfrench-calfgoodyear-welteuropean-craftsmanship

Carmina offers bespoke-level finishing at a mid-range price point, using high-grade French calfskin and a closed-channel Goodyear welt. The 'Forest' last is widely considered one of the most anatomically correct and aesthetically balanced shapes in classic menswear.

Quality Score12/12
Purity
Evidence
Transparency
Value
Strong Evidence
View Details

Ingredients & Purity

Uses full-grain box calf from Tanneries d'Annonay (France); features a bark-tanned leather sole for superior abrasion resistance; cork filling is high-density for better support.

Scientific Evidence

Utilizes a closed-channel stitch (hiding the welt thread), a hallmark of high-end shoemaking that protects the stitching from the elements.

Brand Transparency

Detailed specifications provided for every last (shape) and leather source; manufactured entirely in Mallorca, Spain.

Value Assessment

At roughly $500, this shoe competes directly with brands charging $800+ for the same leather and construction quality.

Why Not Alternatives?

Carmina outclasses Allen Edmonds in finishing quality and leather selection (using top-tier Tanneries d'Annonay) while remaining significantly more affordable than English makers like Edward Green or John Lobb.

More in Footwear