dress-shoes
Park Avenue Cap-Toe Oxford
The Park Avenue is the quintessential American dress shoe, featuring a 360-degree Goodyear welt and an extensive size range (AAA to EEE). It remains a top recommendation due to its massive retail footprint for sizing and its robust recrafting service.
Quality & Materials
Premium calfskin upper; cork-infused midsole for custom foot impressions; custom heel with rubber strike plate for traction.
Evidence & Testing
The 360-degree welt provides more stability than the 270-degree welts used by many European makers, though it results in a chunkier aesthetic.
Brand Transparency
Publicly available information on their 'Recrafting' process and Port Washington, Wisconsin factory operations.
Value Assessment
Best purchased during their 'Anniversary' or 'Rediscover America' sales when prices drop to ~$250-$300; at full MSRP, value is moderate.
Why Not Alternatives?
While leather quality has seen some variance in recent years compared to Carmina, Allen Edmonds offers a much wider range of widths and sizes, making it the best option for those with non-standard feet.
More in Footwear
Vivobarefoot
Primus Lite III
Premium barefoot shoe with foot-shaped toe box, zero-drop sole, thin flexible construction. Recycled PET plastic, plant-based foam. 100-day trial period.
Xero Shoes
HFS II
Exceptional value barefoot shoe with 5,000-mile sole warranty. FeelTrue outsole proven durable over 1,000+ miles. Industry-leading warranty.
Brooks
Glycerin 22
Best premium neutral daily trainer. DNA Tuned nitrogen-infused midsole. HPR Plus outsole more durable than Ghost. Plush yet stable ride.
New Balance
Fresh Foam X 1080 v14
Industry-leading cloud-like cushion. Widened toe box from v13. Named 'best in test' by multiple outlets. Best true daily trainer of 2024.